Passa ai contenuti principali

Post

Visualizzazione dei post da febbraio, 2025

Refutation of the Teleological Argument

  Argument P1. The Universe is ordered. P2. Order requires an intelligent being. C1. From P1 & P2: The Universe requires/d an intelligent being [to organise/program it]. C2. From C1: [Since that being must have existed before the Universe,] That being is God (i.e. God exists). - - - Refutation P1. The Universe is ordered. P2. Order requires an intelligent being [to organise/program it]. P3. There are intelligent beings in the Universe. C1. From P1 & P2: The Universe requires/d an intelligent being [to organise/program it]. C2. From C1: [Since that being must have existed before the Universe,] That being is God (i.e. God exists). C3. From P1 & P3: Intelligence is ordered [because if it weren't, it would make the Universe chaotic, which would contradict P1]. C4. From P2 & C3: Intelligent beings require/d an intelligent being [to organise/program them]. C5. From C2 & C4: God requires/d an intelligent being [to organise/program him]. C6. From C5 & C4: The intell...